Many people assume that making a will gives them complete freedom to leave their property to whoever they wish. In Cyprus, that is not always the case. Where Cyprus law governs the succession, the Wills and Succession Law, Cap. 195, reserves a portion of the estate for certain family members, regardless of what the will provides. This portion is commonly referred to as the legal share, also called the statutory or reserved portion. For deaths since 17 August 2015, whether Cyprus law governs is decided by Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, the EU Succession Regulation: ordinarily it is the law of the country where the deceased was habitually resident at death (Article 21(1)).

How the legal share works

Section 41 of Cap. 195 splits an estate into a disposable portion, which the will controls, and the legal share, which belongs to the family whatever the will says. The proportions depend on who survives the deceased. Where a child or a descendant of a child survives, with or without a spouse, only one quarter of the net estate can be disposed of freely; the remaining three quarters are reserved. Where a spouse or a parent survives but no child or descendant, half is disposable. Only a person who leaves no spouse, no child or descendant of a child, and no parent may dispose of the whole estate by will.

A will that overreaches is not void. It is cut back: effective as to the disposable portion, ineffective to the extent it invades the legal share. A will leaving everything to one person, where the law reserves three quarters for the family, takes effect only as to the quarter; if that person is also one of the heirs, they take a share of the reserved three quarters as well (section 50). The one exception to cutting back is a deceased who leaves a spouse but no child, descendant or parent: a gift to that spouse beyond the disposable half stands.

Suppose a man dies leaving a net estate of €600,000, a wife and two children, and a will leaving everything to his wife. The will takes effect as to €150,000. The remaining €450,000 is shared equally by the wife and the two children, since a surviving spouse takes a share equal to each child’s (section 44), so the wife ends with €300,000 and each child with €150,000. Where there is no will at all, the whole estate passes under Part III of Cap. 195 (sections 44 to 51), the same rules that divide the legal share when there is a will.

The executor’s role

The appointment of an executor does not change these rules. Under section 41 of the Administration of Estates Law, Cap. 189, the executor collects the estate and pays the funeral expenses and debts. The executor then carries out the will according to the law, cutting the legacies back proportionately where the will gives away more than the disposable portion, and distributes the legal share as the law directs. An executor who distributes the estate in breach of these duties may incur personal liability for any resulting loss, and the court may remove an executor for wilful default or misconduct (section 52).

What changed in 2015

For decades section 42 of Cap. 195 disapplied the legal share in two cases: the will of a person born in the United Kingdom, or whose father was born in the United Kingdom or in any Commonwealth country, and a will of movable property made by anyone who was not a citizen of the Republic, with limited exceptions. Many expatriates built their plans on it. Section 42 was deleted by the Wills and Succession (Amendment) Law of 2015, Law 96(I)/2015, published on 3 July 2015, some six weeks before the EU Succession Regulation began to apply.

For deaths after the repeal took effect, the exception is gone wherever Cyprus law governs the succession, whatever the testator’s descent or nationality, and the date the will bears does not revive it. Older wills of foreign nationals turn on one qualification: under Article 83(4) of the Regulation, a will made before 17 August 2015 in accordance with the law of the testator’s nationality may be treated as a choice of that law. Wills drafted around the old section 42 should be reviewed now, starting with that question.

Estate planning options

For nationals of other countries, Article 22 of the Regulation allows a person to choose, in the will, the law of their nationality to govern succession to their whole estate. The choice is available whether or not the country of nationality is an EU Member State (Article 20). A British national can therefore choose the law of the relevant part of the United Kingdom; where validly made, such a choice should mean that the succession is governed by the chosen national law rather than by Cyprus succession law, including its rules on the legal share. The choice should be made expressly; leaving it to be inferred from the terms of the will invites argument later. An express choice also rules out renvoi, where one country’s law sends the question on to another’s (Article 34(2)). Without one, where the deceased lived outside the EU, that country’s own rules may send Cyprus land back to Cyprus law, and the Regulation accepts the referral (Article 34(1)(a)).

Beyond that, the legal share bites only on what is in the estate at death. Assets validly given away during the person’s lifetime, or settled into a properly constituted trust, are not part of the estate. Gifts to children are the partial exception: a child who takes part of the legal share must bring into account lifetime provision received from the parent, including property given under a marriage contract or as a dowry, unless the will provides otherwise (section 51 of Cap. 195).

A Cyprus International Trust, established under the International Trusts Law, Law 69(I)/1992, benefits from statutory protection against the application of succession and inheritance laws, whether under Cyprus law or the law of another country. Its creation is, however, subject to specific residence requirements, among other conditions. For more on these, see the Insights article on trusts in Cyprus. A domestic trust under the Trustee Law, Cap. 193, may also keep assets outside the estate and so beyond succession claims, although without the express statutory protection a Cyprus International Trust enjoys.

None of these options should be treated as a simple way around the legal share. A lifetime gift must involve a genuine transfer of ownership, a trust must be properly constituted and administered, and a choice of law must satisfy the requirements of the Regulation.

This article is provided for general information only. It is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific professional advice should be sought before acting on anything it discusses.

If you have any queries, please contact Orestis Laos LLC